PDA

View Full Version : another negligence question


MImaggie
10-18-2006, 10:16 AM
i'm looking for answers for my 22 year old daughter. it's a long story, but i will try to keep it relatively brief.

up until about 6 weeks ago, she was perfectly healthy and fully functional, working, going to school, raising her son and planning her wedding.


she developed some abdominal pain, mentioned it to her GYN and was referred to another doc. then the fun began. he diagnosed her with ulcers and prescribed 3 medications.


after about 10 days, she began having more abdominal pain, and dry heaves, so she called his office and was told by the receptionist (not medically trained) to come in IMMEDIATELY.

Dr. berated her for not giving the meds a chance to work, and she informed him that HIS office staff told her to rush over. he then asked her what meds she was taking (info was NOT in her chart). he then told her she was "just having a panic attack" and prescribed Xanax and Zoloft. this was on top of Reglan, Prilosec and Carafate (?-some relatively benign GI med). this was a Thursday.


Friday, she had a crying jag, slept most of the day, and episodes of simply staring into space. Saturday, her fiance called me in a panic-she was crying hysterically, could not speak, her body was jerking uncontrollably.
off to the ER.
Three ER visits, one inpatient stay, and two neurologist visits later, she is now being referred to a movement disorders clinic with a pretty significant essential tremor that probably is permanent.



she can't work, she is afraid to drive. the slightest amount of stress sets her body shaking.


most physicians have dropped thier jaws when they see what meds she was prescribed originally. from all accounts, it was the Reglan that triggered the entire thing, and another GI doc has said he would never have prescribed it in the first place. one neuro said that she was prescribed a "serious" dosage, and he would have tapered up to that high a dose.


she has been jerked around by the entire medical community-the neuro prescribed one drug, the internal med guy discontinued it and prescribed another with out telling the neuro. the ER docs at our local hospital were profoundly insulting and dismissive. but i think the original doc bears the brunt of the culpability for the situation.



he has a bad rep in the community and his office is a HIPAA nightmare he walks down the hall, dictacting into a tape recorder, patient names and diagnosis (she overheard while waiting in the exam room), files out in the open where anyone could read-no locked cabinets, no locked anything.

when she was preparing the records for her second neuro opinion,
she realized she did not have the notes from the original doctor. she called his office, and yes, they have had her signed authorization for nearly a month, but have "not gotten around to it".

she asked if she could come and pick them up. no, doctor refuses to give records to patients. (OH REALLY?!?!!?). she asked if they could be faxed. no, doctor does not fax records. they will be sent via snail mail "when they get around to it". i counted, and this happened on day 28 after they first recieved her signed authorization and request. to the best of my knowledge, the records still have not been recieved, and we are WELL past the thirty day HIPAA requirement.


working in medical (psychology practice), i cannot tell you how many alarm bells this set off for me.

opinions???

lor
04-26-2007, 01:39 PM
MImaggi, GADS..How is she now? Combining all those meds might have been the biggest problem. I wonder if those next drugs he prescribed could even be taken while she was taking those first ones. And I believe it is the patiets legal right to have/get their own records.

Cry Tears
04-27-2007, 03:22 PM
I'm so sorry for your daughter.
If I were you I'd contact an attorney to help guide these docs into doing their job.
They know which set of "teeth" is needed to put a bite into some buttinski's!
I've been thru more than my share of medical nightmares and sad to say, never had as much as a snide "sorry" out of any of them.
The worst one was my ER visit for extreme fatigue, dizzyness, swollen ankles, chest pains, feeling cold despite a hot day, racing heart....all diagnosed as panic attack and inner ear virus. :eek:
This ER doc refused to order simple blood samples and dishcharged me from ER telling me I wasn't "that" ill! :(

2 weeks later I "fell asleep" while driving my car, crossed over 2 lanes head on ..I'd just dropped off grandkids thank GOD!
At a different hospital blood test done...I was missing 2/3 of my blood...yes...you read that right!
I should have been dead!
I had an intestinal anuerism the size of a baseball that kept bleeding... not a panic attack!
And anyone missing that much blood would have felt the way I did.
None of my doctors can figure out how I was able to even stand up let alone drive and function as I did...I should have been dead!
Even more unbeleivable was why I was never given basic care in the first place as I had all the signs of severe anemia.
I'd only visited that ER once in 17 years, so not one who kept going in seeking attention like that ER "doc" claimed.
And I don't look like a homeless or indegant person...am hospital volunteer to boot!
My experience opened my eyes and I lost respect in anyone wearing a white coat as I once wore years ago when I was healthy.
I was too ill for several years after this experience to seek an attorney.
Looking back I wish to God I would have at least put this in an attorneys hands...I could have at least gotten a little satisfaction and something for the pain and suffering I experienced by being sent away when I sought treatment.
I wonder how many people have died from this HPPA crap everyone's sick of!?!? Probably more than we could ever know.
The laws in place supposed to protect....PRIVACY!?!?!? Who are we kidding?
This has gone way too far....and soon will swing back in another direction, hopefully to a happy medium.

Keep fighting for your daughters health...leave no stone unturned.
You must educate yourself on every issue in order to help her make good decisions.
Sadly you are learning what a lot of us here have too many times.
If most of us had the energy we'd slap the roll eyes right off their faces!

I hope your daughter will allow you to help guide her in the directions she needs to go.
I pray she will be healthy enough to walk down the isle and enjoy a wonderful life ahead of her.
She's lucky to have such a caring and supportive family, the most important factor!
Blessings, cheryl
PS...not to make this story about me...but I"m on a roll here...
My 36 year old husband had a sore on his tongue. Our usual doc out of town, his fill in told my hubby to take the antibiotics, he'd just bitten his tongue despite my husband very adamat he'd not done so, begged it to be removed.
My husband travels all over the US doing 911 systems and when there's an emergency with a system he must go.
He was going to be gone a month and wanted this removed before he left.
But this doc refused to listen, told my husaband "I'm a medical doctor, you're only a patient! YOU BITE YOURSELF! so take the meds and quit whining!"
My husand was a non smoker, non chewer, non drinker as is usual for tongue and mouth cancer.
A month later when my husband returend he saw our regular doctor.
Alarmed at its size, it was biopsied immediatly.
Was now a marble sized tumour squamis cell carcinoma, the worst form mouth cancer possible!
Deadly! With only a 15% 5 year survival rate.
Because it was let go for so long my husband suffered from the long term effect of radiation.
Had they removed it in early stage he would not have needed radiation.
My husband now has time bomb cells making more tumours, all from radiation 20 years ago.
Very very sad case....and we didn't sue then either only because my husband was so ill for so long.

michael178
05-16-2007, 04:26 PM
medical claims are very hard to deal with. They are very expensive and there are many excellent attorneys who want nothing to do with them.
Getting an attorney will probably be very difficult, and being able to prevail is even harder...I just want to warn you...the cards are stacked against you.

Lea
05-19-2007, 09:05 PM
You need to make a complaint to the AMA in your state and Insurance Commission pronto! The HIPPA violations alone are enough to get this doc in hot water,not to mention the fact that your daughter may have a permanent case of EPS from the Reglan. You have documentation of the harm she suffered and their refusal to get her her records in a timely manner is a big fat red flag.

I think you have a very good case against this doctor and I disagree that a lawyer wouldn't touch this.

JAVISI
06-07-2007, 11:04 AM
My Gastrenterologist will not prescribe Reglan to me. He told me of many people with Parkinsons or similar disorders can become much worse in respect to the tremors. Once they come off of the med some get better and some just don't!:( That is a scarey thought!

It is unfortunate that many Dr's have a God complex. O9r they tend to lump people in to baskets. Drug seekers, needy people ect. If they would take the time to really hear what you are saying, their would be many less problems.

It is very hard to win a law suit against a Dr. But you should definatly contact the AMA in your state! You could call a lawyer that deals in malpractice cases, If they think that you will win they will take on your case, They won't take it on if they don't think that they will win. After all most work on a percentage basis. The world and care/malpractice should not be a factor but it often plays a role.

Good Luck, Javisi;)

my3ccc
12-12-2007, 08:39 AM
Hey If you believe that you may have a case. It's reason to let an attorney review your med records. Good luck to all.

hodsdonn
06-21-2009, 11:41 AM
First, what a wonderful mother your daughter has. your daughter should pursue this matter, especially since there could be long term effects from the medications. What I find even more appalling is the arrogance of the physicians involved and the blatant HIPPA violations.